wintersmom - have you seen the thread http://unclutterer.com/discuss/topic/negative-responses-to-my-declutter-talk ?
The bottom line there is, it's about you and how you feel, and once other people gave you something, it is out of their jurisdiction (haha) and now you can do with it as you please. Also, with all due respect, 2) is very wrong and somehow something only mothers can get away with. It's wrong because -you- care. Whether you walk the streets of Paris everyday or not, you deserve to feel good in your own clothes. If you sit alone at home and feel boring in what you wear, it's a fact that it's time to throw out some clothes and get a few new ones to un-boring things.
If you still wonder what to tell your mom in case she asks (like everyone in that thread says, don't tell her! The topic will likely never come up), try taking a piece of paper before and writing down arguments. Like "Her: It doesn't matter what you wear, noone else sees you anyway - Me: I see me, and that's enough. - Her: You should give them to me if you don't like them. - Me: If you liked them, you would have kept them. Now they are mine to deal with." and so on. Keep going until you're out of arguments for each side. It feels stupid to write this down first, but it's a technique that has been proven to work well for people suffering from depression and/or negative self-talk, it prepares you for the conversation if it will take place, and it shows you what is important to you :o)
Oh and on a side note: I loved your "Wow, her life is SO busy and interesting...she doesn't even have the time to think about her clothes!" On Friday night I went out with my friends and thought I was a bit underdressed and, well, "booooring" again, then I thought of that and it made me smile :o)
And I love vjb's suggestions, too. I like the probation thing for clothes with the turned hangers, and I also like the "keep only stuff you get compliments in". If I did that, I'd only be walking around in a scarf I bought in Prague and in the colorful woolen socks my mom knit for me! A bit chilly, but yes, a lot less "boring"! Hee hee ;o)
