ArtGal, I just ended up putting everything from my desk into a container. It is the last real area in my current uncluttering activities. It is liberating to just sit down at a clear space. (Although I had to go back really quickly and save my mouse from the box, it would have made using my computer a bit difficult. :P)
I did not put my box away, it is sitting on the floor next to me. I think if I were to clear things off one my one I would have never had the chance to realize how much I like this space. And yes, some things will be returned, my metal organizer for papers because they are needed for me to do everything I need to do. However, by cup of pens and pencils and such will be gone. I really don't need more than one out at a time.